Post by Her3tiK on Apr 3, 2011 20:14:00 GMT -5
ETA: It has been brought to my attention that some of what is written is quite graphic, and that this post should have had a warning on it. My apologies for not including this the first time around.
scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2011/04/shades_of_gray.php
Whether or not you agree with PZ Myers's blunt approach to religion, this is something completely worth reading. Very rarely do I come across something so well written that I am left completely speechless; this is one of those times.
He goes on to write some incredibly well-detailed events that closely mirror the ways in which we kill one another for what are, in the end, completely stupid and arbitrary reasons. I'd like to think that he's not writing about real people and omitting their names, but it really is difficult to tell. For example:
I strongly recommend reading the entire piece. It's incredibly powerful, and drives home a point I think everyone on this board can agree upon.
scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2011/04/shades_of_gray.php
Whether or not you agree with PZ Myers's blunt approach to religion, this is something completely worth reading. Very rarely do I come across something so well written that I am left completely speechless; this is one of those times.
But sometimes the issues are black and white. Sometimes the answers are clear and absolute. And in those cases, attempts to bring out the watercolors and soften the story by blurring the edges do a disservice to reality. There are places where there are no ambiguities, and the only appropriate response is flat condemnation. And we witness them every day.
All around the world, people are killing and being killed; they are crossing the clearest, least arbitrary border we have. You don't come back from death, and you can't atone for extinguishing another life. There are no excuses. Life is not a video game, where your targets are smears of pixels with no history and no awareness. In the real world, those bodies are people, with 20 years or 30 years or 50 years or 70 years of stories and connections behind them, part of a web of humanity, and their every action tugs on the people around them. Dehumanizing them, as we often do, dehumanizes us. You are the killer, but you are also the killed.
All around the world, people are killing and being killed; they are crossing the clearest, least arbitrary border we have. You don't come back from death, and you can't atone for extinguishing another life. There are no excuses. Life is not a video game, where your targets are smears of pixels with no history and no awareness. In the real world, those bodies are people, with 20 years or 30 years or 50 years or 70 years of stories and connections behind them, part of a web of humanity, and their every action tugs on the people around them. Dehumanizing them, as we often do, dehumanizes us. You are the killer, but you are also the killed.
He goes on to write some incredibly well-detailed events that closely mirror the ways in which we kill one another for what are, in the end, completely stupid and arbitrary reasons. I'd like to think that he's not writing about real people and omitting their names, but it really is difficult to tell. For example:
…you watch the crowd fill the streets, and when the numbers seem adequate, you tap the numbers into your cell phone, and instantly the car blooms into a flare of fire, and as you watch the bodies fly and flail away from it, you hear the rumbling thud of the detonation. You rush forward with everyone else — it wouldn't do to be spotted guiltily scuttling away — and you see one of the enemy lying in the road, eyes blinking in shock, staring at the sky. You watch the lips move, but no sound emerges — you know the shock wave of the explosion would have pulped lungs that now lie in sodden useless tatters in the chest. The target tries to cough, spasms, blood gushes from mouth and nose, and then the feeble movements end, and the eyes glaze, seeing nothing ever again.
…you join friends as you walk to the market, when a great hand lifts you and flings you against a wall and bounces you into the street. You can't hear anything but an overwhelming ringing; you feel disoriented and confused; something is wrong with your body, it feels weak and helpless. You look up at the sky, it's clear and blue and beautiful, and you dream that your mother will come and pick you up and all will be well, so you try to call out to her, but you can't catch your breath, and all you feel is a vast welling bubble of pain rising up and up and breaking…and then darkness.
Your mother arrives later, with people from all around the neighborhood. They file through the makeshift morgue, sorting through the bloody clothing and the shattered body parts, trudging through a charnel house to identify their loved ones, or fragments of them. One of the attendants has washed the blood and dust from your face and, unlike so many others, you look like one sleeping — your mother hopefully puts a hand to your cheek, feels the chilled motionlessness, and knows there is no hope ever again, and feels a shadow of that rising bubble of anguish herself.
…you join friends as you walk to the market, when a great hand lifts you and flings you against a wall and bounces you into the street. You can't hear anything but an overwhelming ringing; you feel disoriented and confused; something is wrong with your body, it feels weak and helpless. You look up at the sky, it's clear and blue and beautiful, and you dream that your mother will come and pick you up and all will be well, so you try to call out to her, but you can't catch your breath, and all you feel is a vast welling bubble of pain rising up and up and breaking…and then darkness.
Your mother arrives later, with people from all around the neighborhood. They file through the makeshift morgue, sorting through the bloody clothing and the shattered body parts, trudging through a charnel house to identify their loved ones, or fragments of them. One of the attendants has washed the blood and dust from your face and, unlike so many others, you look like one sleeping — your mother hopefully puts a hand to your cheek, feels the chilled motionlessness, and knows there is no hope ever again, and feels a shadow of that rising bubble of anguish herself.
I strongly recommend reading the entire piece. It's incredibly powerful, and drives home a point I think everyone on this board can agree upon.
She sounds like she was a fun chick, but isn't she a "people" too?